Sort articles by: Date | Most Rates | Most Views | Comments | Alphabet

Ahmad al-Hassan fails due to ignorance! - Shocking!

Author: Rasul on 11-01-2015, 17:55, Views: 8823

70

بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم

 

السلام عليكم

 

The following arguments, has been used by Ahmad al-Hassan in his book: ''The thirteenth disciple'', in order to refute Sheikh Tusi's (ra) interpretation.

 

ثم من هم الذين يعتقدون بأ ن الإمام المهدي محمد بن الحسن ميت في زمن الظهور كما صرح الشيخ الطوسي ويعتقد أكثر الناس أنه بلي عظامه؟!! فالشيعة يعتقدون بحياته والسنة لا يعتقدون بوجوده أصلا فكيف يعتقدون بموته

 

[Ahmad al-Hassan says]: ''Moreover, who are those who believe that Imam al-Mahdi, Muhammad bin al-Hassan, is dead in the "Age of Appearance" as Sheikh al-Tousi stated, "And most of the people believe that his bones have deteriorated"?!! For the Shia believe that he is alive and the Sunnis do not believe that he is present in the first place so how can they believe in his death?!!!''

 

 

_______________________

 

Anṣārī References:

Source: al-Hawwari al-Thalith Ashar by Ahmad al-Hassan, page 141,

 

 

(Click on the image below - in order to enlarge ;)

Ahmad al-Hassan fails due to ignorance! - Shocking!

Ahmad al-Hassan fails due to ignorance! - Shocking!

 

 

 

Claims made by Ahmad al-Hassan:

  1. Shia believe that he [i.e. 12th Imam (as)] is alive.
  2. Sunnis do not believe, that he [i.e. 12th Imam (as)] is present.

 

Questions asked by Ahmad al-Hassan:

  1. So, how can they [i.e. Sunnis & Shiites] believe in his death?
  2. Who are those who believe that Imam al-Mahdi, Muhammad bin al-Hassan, is dead in the "Age of Appearance"?

 

 

I say: In defence of Sheikh Tusi (ra) statement, ''And most of the people believe that his bones have deteriorated." The statement of Sheikh Tusi (ra) is about Shiites, who made such claims due to prolongation of the occultation, because of their ignorance. They were refuted later on.

 

In the book by Abdulaziz Abdulhussein Sachedina: ''Islamic Messianism: The Idea of Mahdi in Twelver Shi'ism, page 84, we can read the following: ''The occultation was already considered as tawil when Ibn Babuya composed his Kamal al-Din. In one place he relates his meeting with a man in Baghdad who complained to him that the ghayba had become prolonged and unbearable confusion had caused many Shi'ites to turn away from the Imamate of the Twelfth Imam because of the long occultation."

 

Also, when we refer to the Kitāb al-G̲h̲ayba of Sheikh al-Tusi, we can read the following, which supports our statement:

 

قال: وروى أحمد بن الحارث، رفعه إلى أبي عبد الله عليه السلام أنه قال: لو قد يقوم القائم لقال الناس: أنى يكون هذا وبليت عظامه

 

[Fii Nusrat al-Waqifa]: He said: Ahmad b. al-Harith narrated, going up to Abu `Abdillah (as) that he said: "When the Qa’im rises, the people will say: Is this the one, while his bones had decayed?"[1]

 

فإنما فيه: أن قوما يقولون: إنه بليت عظامه لانهم ينكرون أن يبقى هذه المدة الطويلة. وقد إدعى قوم أن صاحب الزمان مات وغيبه الله فهذا رد عليهم

 

[Sheikh al-Tusi says]: "And in this, a community will say, "his bones had decayed" because they will doubt that he had remained for this long period. And a community has claimed that the Patron of the Age has died, and Allah has concealed him – so this is a refutation of them."

 

 

_______________________

 

Shia References:

Source: Kitāb al-G̲h̲ayba by Sheikh al-Tusi, page 59-60,

[1] It is a Waqifi hadith, explained by Sheikh al-Tusi (ra).

 

 

(Click on the image below - in order to enlarge ;)

Ahmad al-Hassan fails due to ignorance! - Shocking!

Ahmad al-Hassan fails due to ignorance! - Shocking!

Ahmad al-Hassan fails due to ignorance! - Shocking!

 

 

I say: As for the statement of Ahmad al-Hassan: "Sunnis do not believe, that he [i.e. 12th Imam (as)] is present." - There are Sunnis who believe, that he [i.e. 12th Imam (as)] was present and that he (as) died. Let's see what Sunni Imam Shāh Abd al-Azīz Dehlavi says, in his book: ''al-Toḥfa al-ʼIthnā ʿAshariyya.''

 

In the introduction of his book, Imam Dehlavi says the following:

 

و این رساله را تیمّناً و تبرّکاً بهٔ عدد ائمه اثنا عشر علیهم السلام بر دوازده باب مرتب کرده شد

 

"And [the contents of] this treatise was sorted into twelve chapters seeking the blessings of the number of the twelve Imams, may Allah's peace be upon them."

 

Also, in the second chapter, he says:

 

تا آنکه نوبت حضرت امام محمد بن الحسن المهدی رسید و ایشان متولد شدند و در حالت طفولیت و صغر سن وفات کردند

 

"Till the turn [of the Imamate] reached Imam Mohammad bin al-Hassan, who was born and then passed away in his childhood."

 

 

_______________________

 

Sunni References:

Source: al-Toḥfa al-Ithnā ʿAshariyya by Imam Dehlavi, page 4 & 206,

 

 

(Click on the image below - in order to enlarge ;)

Ahmad al-Hassan fails due to ignorance! - Shocking!

Ahmad al-Hassan fails due to ignorance! - Shocking!

Ahmad al-Hassan fails due to ignorance! - Shocking!

 

 

 

Conclusions:

  1. Ahmad al-Hassan is ignorant of the fact, that many Shiites turned away from the Imamat of the 12th Imam (as) due to prolongation of the occultation, and claimed that the Patron of the Age (as) was dead, and that al-Tusi (ra) talks about them.
  2. Claims made by Ahmad al-Hassan are due to his ignorance.
  3. Questions asked by Ahmad al-Hassan are also due to his ignorance.
  4. There are Sunnis who believe, that he [i.e. 12th Imam (as)] was present and that he (as) died.

Category: Articles, Shia Islam, Researches, Ahl al-Bayt (as), Ahmad al-Hassan (la), Shia Reply:, Imamah, Shia ʿAqeedah, Īlm, Ḥadīth, Sharḥ | Explanation, History, Caliphate, Sunni Scholars, Fake Yamani

 

Ahmad al-Hassan & 12 Imams from the children of the Prophet

Author: Rasul on 14-12-2014, 19:58, Views: 897

1

بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم

 

السلام عليكم

 

There are some aḥadīth in Shia books, which give the impression, that there will be thirteen Imams, i.e. Imam Ali (as) + 12 Imams. Such aḥadīth has been used by Ahmad al-Hassan and his helpers, in order to prove, that Ahmad al-Hassan is ''13th Imam''. After referring to the following hadith, we can conclude, that those aḥadīth speak only about 12 Imams (as), and that Ali (as) is first of them.

 

حدثنا علي بن الحسن بن محمد، قال حدثنا الشريف الحسين بن علي بن عبد الله بن الموسى القاضي، قال حدثنا حريز بن عبد الحميد الضبي، قال حدثنا الأعمش، عن إبراهيم يزيد السمان، عن أبيه، عن الحسين بن علي عليهما السلام قال: فقال الأعرابي: أشهد أن لا إله إلا الله وأنك رسول الله حقا، فأخبرني يا رسول الله هل يكون بعدك نبي؟ قال: لا أنا خاتم النبيين، ولكن يكون بعدي أئمة من ذريتي قوامون بالقسط كعدد نقباء بني إسرائيل، أولهم علي بن أبي طالب، فهو الإمام والخليفة بعدي، وتسعة من الأئمة من صلب هذا – ووضع يده على صدري – والقائم تاسعهم يقوم بالدين في آخر الزمان كما قمت في أوله

 

Narrated Ibrahim Yazid as-Samman from his father, that Imam al-Hussain Ibn Ali (as) said: [...] a Bedouin said: "I testify, that lā ilāha illā-llāh [i.e. there is no god but Allah] and I testify that you are really the Rasul-Allah, therefore inform me, will there be a Prophet after you?, O Rasul-Allah! He (saw) said: "No, because I am the seal of the Prophets, but after me, there will be just Imams among my children, equal to the number of the Leaders of the Children of Israel.[1] The first of them is Ali Ibn Abi Talib, because he is the Imam and my Caliph [i.e. successor] after me, and nine are from the progeny of this here [i.e. Hussein (as)]. Then he (saw) put his hand on my chest and said: "The al-Qā’im is the ninth of them. He rises with the religion in the end times, just as I stood with it in the early days."

 

 

_______________________

 

Shia References:

Source: Kifayat al-athar by al-Khazzaz al-Qummī, page 269-270, Hadith # 3 / 106

[1] i.e. Twelve, as mentioned in Quran.

 

 

(Click on the image below - in order to enlarge ;)

Ahmad al-Hassan & 12 Imams from the children of the Prophet

Ahmad al-Hassan & 12 Imams from the children of the Prophet

Ahmad al-Hassan & 12 Imams from the children of the Prophet

Category: Articles, Shia Islam, Researches, Ahl al-Bayt (as), Ahmad al-Hassan (la), Imamah, Ḥadīth, Sharḥ | Explanation, Caliphate, Fake Yamani

 

al-Yamani from Yemen in Shia Hadith | Muhaddith al-Nūrī at-Ṭabarsī

Author: Rasul on 16-10-2014, 23:35, Views: 1478

0

بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم

 

السلام عليكم

 

The great Shia scholar in the field of hadith; Muhaddith al-Nūrī at-Ṭabarsī has mentioned in his book; ''Nafas al-Raḥmān fī faḍāʼil Salmān'', after researching about Dajjal, Khorasani and Yamani in Shia hadith, he has said the following about al-Yamani:

 

واليماني من اليمن

 

and [the emergence of] al-Yamani from Yemen.[1]

 

 

_______________________

 

Shia References.

Source: Nafas al-Raḥmān by Muhaddith al-Nūrī at-Ṭabarsī, page 289,

[1] I say: May Allah bless at-Ṭabarsī (ra), for he has said the truth about al-Yamani, and al-Sadiq (as) has said in a Ṣaḥīḥ [authentic] hadith, that al-Yamani will emerge from Yemen with the white flags. - [Read Here].

 

 

(Click on the image below - in order to enlarge ;)

al-Yamani from Yemen in Shia Hadith | Muhaddith al-Nūrī at-Ṭabarsī

al-Yamani from Yemen in Shia Hadith | Muhaddith al-Nūrī at-Ṭabarsī

Category: Articles, Shia Islam, Researches, Ahmad al-Hassan (la), Shia Reply:, Ḥadīth, Sharḥ | Explanation, Fake Yamani

 

Shia Scholars & Ahmad al-Hassan

Author: Rasul on 7-08-2014, 20:27, Views: 1018

0

بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم

 

السلام عليكم

 

Ahmad al-Hassan [himself] and his Anṣār [helpers] claim, that when 12th Imām (as) will reappear he will fight against Twelver Shia [Imamiyyah] Scholars but the truth is that, when 12th Imām (as) will reappear he will fight against al-Batriyyah.(1)

 

ويسير إلى الكوفة، فيخرج منها ستة عشر ألفا من البترية، شاكين في السلاح، قراء القرآن، فقهاء في الدين، قد قرحوا جباههم، وشمروا ثيابهم، وعمهم النفاق، وكلهم يقولون: يا بن فاطمة، ارجع لا حاجة لنا فيك. فيضع السيف فيهم على ظهر النجف عشية الاثنين من العصر إلى العشاء، فيقتلهم أسرع من جزر جزور، فلا يفوت منهم رجل، ولا يصاب من أصحابه أحد، دماؤهم قربان إلى الله. ثم يدخل الكوفة فيقتل مقاتليها حتى يرضى الله عز وجل

 

Imām al-Bāqir (as) has said: ''[Then he - Imām al-Mahdī] will set out towards Kufa, then from that city 16.000 people of al-Batriyyah will confront him, armed with weapons, reciters of Qur’an, Fuqaha of religion, their foreheads have sign of prostration, their faces are yellow due to fasting, but their aim is hypocrisy, all of them will say: O son of Fatimah (sa) go back, we do not need you, so he will confront them with sword in the back of Kufa, on Monday from noon to evening he will kill them faster than slaughtering the camels. So no one from them will remain and from the companions of Imām (as) no one will get harmed. Their blood is a sacrifice for Allah. Then he will enter Al-Kufa and with fight with its fighter so that Allah is pleased.''

 

 

_______________________

 

Shia References.

Source: Dala'il al-Imamah by Ṭabarī al-Imami, page 239,

(1) al-Batriyyah mix the Wilayat of Ali (as) with the Wilayat of Abu Bakr and Umar and accept them as Imams / Caliphs also.

 

 

(Click on the image below - in order to enlarge ;)

Shia Scholars & Ahmad al-Hassan

Shia Scholars & Ahmad al-Hassan

Category: Articles, Shia Islam, Researches, Ahl al-Bayt (as), Ahmad al-Hassan (la), Ḥadīth, ʿilm al-Rijāl, Sharḥ | Explanation, Batriyyah, Sunni Scholars

 

Did the Iblis become an Angel? - Tafsīr of Ahmad al-Hassan Fails!

Author: Rasul on 4-08-2014, 18:01, Views: 1023

0

بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم

 

السلام عليكم

 

When Ahmad al-Hassan was asked: Is Iblis from the angels or from the Jinn? He answered: Iblis (la) is from the Jinn, but as a result of his worship, he rose in rank until he had become from the Angels, as Jinn rise in rank by their worship and obedience to Allah, until they become Angels. [...] That is why the Quran would sometimes mention Iblis as an Angel.(1)

 

Now, if we refer to the Tafsīr of Ahl al-Bayt (as) we will found out, that the Angels thought that he [Iblīs] was one of them, but he [Iblīs] was not one of them.

 

واما قوله (وإذ قلنا للملائكة اسجدوا لآدم فسجدوا الا إبليس أبى واستكبر وكان من الكافرين) فإنه حدثني أبي عن ابن أبي عمير عن جميل عن أبي عبد الله (ع) قال سئل عما ندب الله الخلق إليه ادخل فيه الضلالة؟ قال نعم والكافرون دخلوا فيه لان الله تبارك وتعالى امر الملائكة بالسجود لآدم فدخل في امره الملائكة وإبليس فان إبليس كان من الملائكة في السماء يعبد الله وكانت الملائكة تظن انه منهم ولم يكن منهم فلما امر الله الملائكة بالسجود لآدم (ع) اخرج ما كان في قلب إبليس من الحسد فعلم الملائكة عند ذلك ان إبليس لم يكن مثلهم فقيل له (ع) فكيف وقع الامر على إبليس وإنما امر الله الملائكة بالسجود لآدم؟ فقال كان إبليس منهم بالولاء ولم يكن من جنس الملائكة وذلك أن الله خلق خلقا قبل آدم وكان إبليس منهم حاكما في الأرض فعتوا وأفسدوا وسفكوا الدماء فبعث الله الملائكة فقتلوهم وأسروا إبليس ورفعوه إلى السماء وكان مع الملائكة يعبد الله إلى أن خلق الله تبارك وتعالى آدم

 

{And when We said to the angels: Make obeisance to Adam they did obeisance, but Iblis [did it not]. He refused and he was proud, and he was one of the unbelievers.}(2) - Imam Ja’far (as) said: [...] "Allah (swt) commanded to the Angels to bow to the Adam, and this order also applied to Iblis. Iblis was with the Angels in the heaven, and worshiped Allah and the Angels thought that he was one of them, but he was not one of them.'' - ''When Allah ordered to the Angels to bow to Adam, what was in the heart of Iblis came out - from the envy, and then the angels knew that he was not one of them.'' [...] The Imam (as) was asked: "How the order of Allah to bow to the Adam could apply to the Iblis, if he was not of the Angels?" He (as) said: "Iblis was in the army of the Angels, but was not created out of their nature, and it is because Allah created the creation before Adam and Iblis was among them the king of the Earth. But they disobeyed and began to make mischief and shed blood, and Allah sent Angels, and they killed them, and took Iblis to the sky, and he worshiped Allah with the Angels until Allah created Adam."

 

 

_______________________

 

Shia References.

Source: Tafsīr al-Qummī by ‘Alī ibn Ibrāhīm al-Qummī, Volume 1, page 35-36,

(1) al-Motashabihat, 1 / 37,

(2) Qurʾān [2:34]

 

 

(Click on the image below - in order to enlarge ;)

Did the Iblis become an Angel? - Tafsīr of Ahmad al-Hassan Fails!

Did the Iblis become an Angel? - Tafsīr of Ahmad al-Hassan Fails!

Did the Iblis become an Angel? - Tafsīr of Ahmad al-Hassan Fails!

Category: Articles, Shia Islam, Researches, Ahl al-Bayt (as), Ahmad al-Hassan (la), Shia Reply:, Īlm, Tafsir, Ḥadīth, Sharḥ | Explanation, History, Fake Yamani

 
Previous Next