» » The chain of the “Will” & Ahmad al-Hassan

 
 
 

The chain of the “Will” & Ahmad al-Hassan

Author: Rasul on 12-11-2014, 15:04, Views: 684

1

بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم

 

السلام عليكم

 

After researching the chain of the hadith [i.e. hadith of the "Will"], mentioned in the ‘Kitāb al-G̲h̲ayba’ by Sheikh al-Tusi (ra), Sheikh ‘Alī Āl Muḥsin states the following:

 

هذه الرواية سندها ضعيف، بل مظلم جدَّاً، وأغلب رواتها مجاهيل، لم يرد لهم ذكر في كتب الرجال، لا بمدح ولا بقدح

 

"This report, its chain is ḍa’īf [weak], in fact very unreliable, and the majority of its narrators are majāhīl [unknown narrators]. No mention is made of them in the books of al-Rijāl, no praise and no condemnation."

 

 

_______________________

 

Shia References:

Source: Radd al-qāṣim by Sheikh ‘Alī Āl Muḥsin, page 28,

[Note]: Scholars, who had researched the chain of the hadith, have come to the conclusion, that the hadith has been narrated through Ammah [i.e. Sunnis]. Refer to the article: The "Will" & Ahmad al-Hassan. It should be noted also, that there is another hadith about Prophet's (saw) ''Will''. Refer to the article: Ahmad al-Hassan - mentioned in the "Will"?.

 

 

(Click on the image below - in order to enlarge ;)

The chain of the “Will” & Ahmad al-Hassan

The chain of the “Will” & Ahmad al-Hassan

Dear visitor, you are browsing our website as Guest.
We strongly recommend you to register and login to view hidden contents.
<
  • 14 Comment
  • 0 Article
  • ICQ:
19 April 2016 13:33

Kosterchik

Reply
  • Group: Members
  • Register date: 19.04.2016
  • Status: Currently Offline
 
Поиграть в игровые автоматы можно бесплатно! Например вот Игровые автоматы pirates treasure смело заходите и выигрывайте!


Add comments

Name:*
E-Mail:
Comment:
Security Code: *